30% off your first 3 months

Get the deal

How to write an argumentative essay

An argumentative essay takes a clear position on a question people disagree about and proves it with evidence.

Guide 8 of 10
Chalk: the claim Ban phones in class, underlined in blue. Below: They say: families need to reach kids. Then the rebuttal, with But circled: the office passes on calls.
Claim, reasons, then the other side. Answer it: the rebuttal.

Why it works. Answering the other side makes your argument stronger, not weaker. A reader who already has an objection in mind stops trusting an essay that ignores it, and trusts one that takes it on fairly.


Your turn

Which sentence is a rebuttal for an essay arguing that phones should be banned in class? A) Phones distract students during lessons. B) Some parents want to reach their children during the day. C) The front office can pass on urgent calls, so phones are not needed in class. Type A, B or C.

Or just show the answer

C

C answers an objection to the ban. B is the objection itself, the other side, and A is a reason for the ban rather than a reply to anything.


Watch out for

  • Mistake 1. Struck through: my side only; written over it: they say, but....

    Ignoring the other side.

    Name the strongest objection and answer it in its own paragraph.

  • Answering a weak version of the objection, a straw man.

    Answer the version a smart opponent would actually make.

  • Mistake 3. Struck through: Everyone hates it.; written over it: A class survey shows....

    Feelings instead of evidence: Everyone hates phones in class.

    Give evidence a reader can check: a survey, a study, a real example.


Stuck on your own homework?

Open DuckyHelper and say it out loud. It sees your screen, so it works through your own problem with you and draws it, like the board above.

“Can you find the strongest objection to my argument so I can answer it?”

Plus is $14 a month for your first 3 months. DuckyHelper is an app for Mac (Apple silicon, macOS 14 or later), Windows and Linux.


Read the whole guide as text

An argumentative essay takes a clear position on a question people disagree about and proves it with evidence. It has an introduction ending in the thesis, body paragraphs that each give one reason with evidence, a paragraph that states the strongest opposing view and answers it, and a conclusion.

Worked example

Write a counterargument and rebuttal for the thesis: Our school should ban phones during class.

  1. State the strongest objection fairly: Some families say students need phones to be reached in an emergency.
  2. Grant what is true in it: Families do need a way to reach students.
  3. Answer it: The front office can pass on urgent calls, so phones are not needed in class.

Answer: Some families say students need phones to be reached in an emergency. Families do need a way to reach students, but the front office can pass on urgent calls, so phones are not needed in class.

Sources

Essay Writing: all 10 guides
Questions and jobs

Do anything

Ask it a question or hand it a job, in any app.

Doing jobs for you is in the Mac app. Asking works on Mac, Windows and Linux.