30% off your first 3 months

Get the deal

How to write a compare and contrast essay

A compare and contrast essay shows how two things are alike and different, then argues what those likenesses and differences reveal.

Guide 9 of 10
Chalk: paper book: easy to lend; e-book: holds hundreds; then so what?, circled in blue, the thesis says.
List the likenesses and differences. Then say what they show.

Why it works. A list of similarities and differences is only notes. The essay becomes an argument when the thesis says what the comparison shows, such as which choice suits whom, or what one thing reveals about the other.


Your turn

Which thesis goes beyond listing? A) Cats and dogs are both popular pets. B) Cats and dogs differ in many ways. C) Cats suit busy owners better than dogs, because they need less time outdoors. Type A, B or C.

Or just show the answer

C

C says what the comparison shows, which pet suits which owner, and why. A and B only report that the two are alike or different.


Watch out for

  • Mistake 1. Struck through: Cats and dogs differ.; written over it: Cats suit busy owners..

    Listing without a point: Cats and dogs are different in many ways.

    End the introduction with what the comparison shows: Cats suit busy owners better than dogs.

  • Spending most of the essay on one of the two.

    Give both subjects the same attention on each point you compare.

  • Mistake 3. Struck through: A's price, B's color; written over it: A's price, B's price.

    Comparing different features: one thing's price with the other's color.

    Compare the same feature for both: price with price, size with size.


Stuck on your own homework?

Open DuckyHelper and say it out loud. It sees your screen, so it works through your own problem with you and draws it, like the board above.

“Can you help me choose between point by point and subject by subject for my essay?”

Plus is $14 a month for your first 3 months. DuckyHelper is an app for Mac (Apple silicon, macOS 14 or later), Windows and Linux.


Read the whole guide as text

A compare and contrast essay shows how two things are alike and different, then argues what those likenesses and differences reveal. Organize it either subject by subject, all of one thing and then all of the other, or point by point, one feature at a time for both. Point by point usually makes the comparison easier to follow.

Worked example

Turn this comparison into a thesis: paper books and e-books.

  1. List what is the same: both hold the same story.
  2. List what differs: a paper book needs no battery and is easy to lend; an e-reader holds hundreds of books and lets you change the text size.
  3. Say what it adds up to, and for whom.

Answer: E-books suit travelers and readers who need bigger text, while paper books suit anyone who wants to lend, write in or keep a book.

Sources

Essay Writing: all 10 guides
Questions and jobs

Do anything

Ask it a question or hand it a job, in any app.

Doing jobs for you is in the Mac app. Asking works on Mac, Windows and Linux.